Managing 50 or more subcontractors under CIS is no small task. Between monthly returns, verification rules, payment statements, and tax deductions – it’s a compliance minefield. And when things go wrong? HMRC doesn’t mess around. CIS Penalties can rack up fast – £100 per late return, rising monthly, with no maximum cap for large businesses.
In this guide, we’ll show you how to avoid CIS penalties when managing a large subcontractor base, and how to put smart systems in place that save you time, money, and stress.
⚠️ Common CIS Mistakes That Trigger Penalties
Here are the most frequent issues we see in larger construction firms:
-
Submitting CIS returns after the 19th of the month
-
Forgetting to verify new subcontractors
-
Incorrect or incomplete deduction statements
-
Applying the wrong tax deduction (20%, 30%, or gross)
-
Not separating labour and materials correctly on invoices
-
Poor record-keeping – especially if HMRC asks for an audit
Each of these can result in fines, backdated tax, or damage to your gross payment status.
✅ How to Stay Compliant with 50+ Subcontractors
1. Automate CIS Where Possible
Manual CIS processing is risky when handling dozens of subcontractors.
Use software like:
-
Xero with CIS module
-
BrightPay for payroll + CIS
-
SubbieHub for subcontractor onboarding and verification
-
QuickBooks with CIS features
These systems help:
-
File returns on time
-
Auto-verify subcontractors
-
Calculate deductions accurately
-
Generate and send statements in bulk
2. Create a Solid Subcontractor Onboarding Process
Standardise the way you bring subcontractors into your business:
-
Collect UTR, NI/company number, VAT status
-
Verify with HMRC before any payment
-
Issue a clear contract that separates materials and labour
-
Record the HMRC verification number and rate
Do this once, do it right – and avoid 30% emergency deductions.
3. Use a CIS Compliance Checklist Every Month
When managing 50+ subcontractors, don’t rely on memory. Create a monthly CIS checklist:
-
All new subcontractors verified with HMRC
-
Invoices checked for labour vs materials
-
Deductions calculated and recorded
-
CIS return submitted by the 19th
-
Payment and deduction statements issued
-
Digital records stored securely
4. Stay on Top of Deadlines
HMRC imposes automatic penalties for late CIS returns:
| Days Late | Penalty |
|---|---|
| 1 day | £100 |
| 2 months | £200 |
| 6 months | £300 or 5% of CIS due |
| 12 months | £300 or up to 100% of CIS due |
If you manage 50+ subcontractors, this can snowball quickly.
Set calendar reminders. Use automated filing. Assign the task to a dedicated team member—or outsource it.
5. Outsource CIS if It’s Slowing You Down
With a large workforce, CIS becomes a full-time job. Consider outsourcing to a construction-specific accountant who can:
-
Verify subs and manage all HMRC submissions
-
Ensure every deduction is calculated correctly
-
Maintain compliant digital records
-
Deal with HMRC if penalties are raised
It’s one of the simplest ways to reduce admin and avoid fines.
👷♂️ Real-World Example: How One Firm Avoided £6,000 in Penalties
A groundworks contractor we worked with had over 70 subcontractors on their books. CIS was handled manually by an overstretched office manager. They missed two monthly returns – leading to £1,400 in fines and a warning from HMRC.
We helped them:
-
Set up Xero’s CIS module
-
Implement a monthly checklist and review process
-
Take over monthly return submissions
-
File all future returns on time
Result: No further penalties. Subcontractors paid on time. Office staff freed up to focus on running the business.
📞 Need Help Managing CIS for 50+ Subcontractors?
At Thomas Emlyn Ltd, we specialise in helping construction companies stay fully CIS compliant, even with large subcontractor lists.
We handle:
-
Monthly CIS returns
-
Subcontractor verifications
-
Statement generation
-
HMRC penalty disputes
-
Digital record-keeping
Book a free discovery call – we’ll help you avoid penalties and streamline your entire CIS process.
📌 Final Thoughts
Managing CIS for 50+ subcontractors doesn’t need to be stressful. With the right systems (and the right support), you can stay compliant, keep HMRC off your back, and focus on what you do best – building great projects.
